16 Comments

I find myself enjoying Poker Face less and less. I mean I will watch next week, but I don't find myself excited by a renewal. Guess I am just too far from procedurals after all of this "golden tv"

Expand full comment

I was just as moved by TLOU ep 5 as I was by ep 3, but in a different way. Ep 3 was beautiful and moving and actually very hopeful. Ep 5 ripped my heart out! And then ep 6 a few nights ago did it again! I started off seeing this show as probably a lesser version of Station Eleven but I no longer feel that way at all. The performances are all stunning and the writing is incredible and they manage to get some humor/LOL lines in every episode. I'm just blown away.

Expand full comment

God I am just loving Poker Face so much and was thrilled at the renewal (though it was much later than I anticipated!) I too thought the Katy being out of her coma talk was just a ruse by Charlie by the way it was shot, but I guess we'll never know for sure. But I gotta say I was impressed with the chemistry between Natasha Lyonne and Charles Melton and it made me want a romantic tryst episode for Charlie!

I love Tim Blake Nelson so I was kinda sad at how under-utilized he was here, but I also love Charles Melton and this was a nice showcase for hum. They really know what they're doing with guest stars.

Expand full comment

Sorry to ask a boring, mundane access question but... So original "Party Down" episodes are on Hulu - but the new shows are exclusively on Starz... and there's no crossover? (Apologies; I can no longer keep track of who owns who; who partners with who, etc.) I mean, I assume they may eventually wind up on Hulu, I guess - but for now, it's Starz or bust?

Expand full comment

I didn't comment at the time, but I was clearing out old e-mails and saw this and wanted to say that three episodes in I'm very pleased being pandered to. Worf's reveal was rewatched so many times the day that episode came out that it started to feel like the Zapruder film.

"You see, his sword goes back and to the left. AGAIN. Back and to the left..."

Expand full comment

That small yelp from Ellie at the very end of the episode is worthy of an Emmy by itself

Expand full comment

I loved your line - I’m a Star Trek fan and this fan service is very much for me.

Expand full comment

How would you rank all the Star Trek shows (past & present)?

Expand full comment
Feb 17, 2023·edited Feb 17, 2023

I feel like Ellie's being written with an unrealistically broad range, from exuberant joy to leathery stoicism. Much more so than any one person would/could encompass. Years of PeakTV have left me accustomed to story-serving-characters rather than vice versa.

Bella Ramsey (who I was late to identify as Lady Mormont from GOT) is a capable enough actress to sell the "Ok, they're all dead, let's swallow our feelings and get moving" stoicism of the final scene. But while it's believable that such a kid might be so hardened and calcified, that's just not the emotionally open character we've been watching (and who had to be written that way to counterpoint Joe's numb crustiness). I get that the writers want to inject complexity into a familiar sort of onscreen relationship, but IMO it should flow more organically.

Again, Ramsey sells it, but it leaves a 90s-style TV taste in my mouth. When writers view characters as pliant chess pieces, I feel disrespected as a viewer. Contrast with the way characters are written in, say, "Better Call Saul" (fwiw I reject the notion Action ought to be broader and more plot-driven)

Expand full comment